Digital vs print yearbooks: How to choose which is best

What print and digital yearbooks each do well, how they compare on cost, signing, sharing, privacy and how long they last, and the questions to settle before you choose.
A group of 4 happy friends in the school cafeteria.
Table of contents
Share

Choose a printed yearbook if it’s meant to be signed, kept on a shelf and opened in twenty years without a device or a login. Choose a digital yearbook if budget, speed or reach matter most, and you’re comfortable that it depends on a file or platform staying available. And you don’t have to pick just one: some schools print the book and share a digital version too.

What is a digital yearbook?

A digital yearbook is a yearbook published to be read on a screen instead of printed. You’ll also see them called online yearbooks or electronic yearbooks. They all mean the same thing, and they can take a few forms:

  • A PDF the school emails to families or posts on its website.
  • A page-turning flipbook hosted on an online publishing platform.
  • An app or website that adds things a book can’t hold, such as video and links.

What goes in is the same as a printed book: the portraits, photos, messages and stories from the year. What changes is how people read it, how long they’ll be able to, and who else can see it.

If you searched for online yearbooks because you’re trying to find an old one, that’s a different job. Our guide to what a school yearbook is explains where to look for old school yearbooks.

Digital printing isn’t a digital yearbook

One bit of printing jargon trips people up. When a printer offers digital printing, it means a way of printing a paper book, not a yearbook you read on a screen. Emroy’s yearbook printing, for example, includes both digital and offset printing, which are two ways of printing a paper book. In this article, a digital yearbook always means one people read on a screen.

Digital vs print yearbooks at a glance

The short version, before the detail:

What mattersPrintDigital
How people read itPick it up and turn the pages. No device or login needed.On a phone, tablet or computer, from anywhere.
SigningFriends sign each other’s copies.No handwritten messages.
CostPrinting, paper, binding and delivery on top of design.No printing costs, so usually cheaper per copy.
Time to publishPrinting and delivery have to fit before the deadline.Quicker, with no print run or delivery.
Fixing mistakesOnce it’s printed, it’s final.Corrections can be made up to the last minute.
Video and linksNot on the page.Can link to video, files and websites.
Long-term accessNeeds nothing but someone to open it.Depends on the file, software and platform still working.
Privacy and sharingGoes to the families who get a copy.Depends on who can reach the file or link.
Best forA keepsake students sign and keep.Tight budgets, close deadlines and families far away.

When is a print yearbook the better choice?

Print earns its place when the yearbook’s job is to be kept. It’s the one students sign and pass around, so the messages friends write in each other’s copies become part of the book. It needs no device, login, internet connection or subscription, so anyone can pick it up and read it, whatever their comfort with technology.

A printed book also works for the school. Leave a copy out at open days or in reception, and prospective families get a picture of school life no brochure can match. We cover that side of it in the hidden school marketing tool you never knew you had.

How long a printed yearbook lasts comes down to what it’s made of. The wrong materials can mean pages falling out within weeks. That’s why we’ve tested hundreds of options for covers, internal pages, finishes, glue and binding for our yearbook design and printing, so the books look right on the day and stay that way for years.

When does a digital yearbook make more sense?

Sometimes digital is simply the right call, and it’s worth saying so plainly. Go digital when:

  • The budget won’t stretch to a printed copy for every family.
  • The deadline is too close to fit in printing and delivery.
  • The book has to reach families who live a long way away.
  • The best content from the year is video, which a page can’t play.

A digital yearbook is quicker and cheaper to produce, because there’s no printing or physical distribution. You can keep correcting mistakes until the last minute, families can view it from anywhere, and it can link out to other files and websites.

What are the downsides of a digital yearbook?

It may not open in twenty years

A printed yearbook needs nothing but someone to open it. A digital one needs a file format, the software to open it and a device to read it, all still working when someone goes looking. Researchers at the National Library of Australia describe file format obsolescence as a major risk to the ongoing usefulness of digital collections.

A yearbook hosted on a platform can only be viewed while the platform keeps it online. Before you commit to one, ask what happens to the yearbook if the school stops paying or the platform closes.

This isn’t a new problem. In 2002, Education Week reported on a US high school that had paired its printed yearbook with a CD of videos and interactive photos every year since 1997. In the same story, another yearbook adviser suggested CDs might become obsolete before print yearbooks did, and said the CD had become a slide show people look at once. When did you last use a CD drive?

Nobody can sign it

Students can’t sign each other’s copies or leave the handwritten messages that turn a yearbook into a keepsake.

It’s easier to share beyond the school

Schools need consent to publish students’ photos, which is why families are usually asked to sign a consent to publish form at the start of each school year. Researchers at the University of Wollongong point out that a child’s photo carries different privacy risks on a school Facebook page, a class learning platform or a printed newsletter, and that parents should be able to consent to one and not another.

So before a yearbook goes online, check that the school’s photo consent covers publishing it that way, and decide who will be able to see it: the whole internet, anyone with the link, or only families who log in.

Is a digital yearbook cheaper?

Usually, per copy. With no printing, paper, binding or delivery, a digital yearbook costs less to produce. But the biggest jobs don’t change with the format. Someone still has to collect the photos and stories, chase contributors, edit the copy and design every page.

For a printed yearbook, the price comes down to how complex the design is, how many pages there are and the print specifications, such as the paper, cover finish and binding. Every school’s mix is different, so the only number worth trusting is a quote for your own book.

How to raise money for your school yearbook A practical guide for yearbook coordinators and P&Cs: who pays, how much to raise, and the fundraising ideas that work…

Can you do both?

Yes, and it can settle the argument. Print the book for the families who want one to keep and sign, and share a digital copy with everyone else, including relatives too far away to see a printed one.

Once the design is finished, the final file is prepared for print, or optimised for viewing online. Our ultimate guide to school yearbooks walks through the whole process. The US school in the Education Week story was doing a version of this back in 2002, with a printed book and a disc of extras.

If you want video or links in the digital version, decide that before design starts, so the pages can be planned around them.

How to choose: questions to ask before you decide

Work through these before you decide:

  • Who is the yearbook for, and will they want to sign it?
  • What’s the budget, and does the school pay or does each family buy a copy?
  • When does it need to be ready, and is there time to print?
  • Should someone be able to open it in twenty years?
  • Does it need video or links?
  • Does the school’s photo consent cover publishing it online, and who will be able to see it?
  • Who will look after the file or platform once this year’s coordinator moves on?

If you’re still split, ask the people it’s for. A quick survey of students and families answers most of these, and if some want print while others are happy with digital, that’s a good case for doing both.

How to organise and run a school yearbook committee So you've been handed the yearbook. This guide covers who to bring on board, what each person does, how to…

Want a printed yearbook without the workload?

Emroy can take the whole book off your plate, from collecting content and chasing contributors to copy editing, design, printing and delivery, all done in Australia. You can be as involved as you like, and we manage the deadlines and reminders along the way.

Share